As of late, an oddly disturbing number of friends, acquaintances, neighbors, and current/former co-workers have been presenting with symptoms of having swallowed a whole lot of propaganda that’s doing odd things to their mental digestive systems, so to speak. I won’t add fuel to any fires by describing these people in terms of geographic origin, gender, economic status, education, occupation, personal wealth, intelligence, or any other label. Doing so would only detract from the process. We’re all being exposed to the same stuff these days, and most of us are reacting the same way. Some of us, however, are not.
Göebbels must have learned this sort of stuff for himself in his, ahh, “focus groups”: when people get stressed, then pushed some more, egged on a little, then pushed some more (repeat this process as necessary) their otherwise sane & functional mental barriers are lowered, and it becomes possible to present all kinds of strange information as “fact”. And I mean “fact” in the most Orwellian sense, as in “.. but we’ve always been at war with Oceana!”
So far I have been dealing with them one-on-one via letters, phone calls, emails, casual encounters, in-person visits, etc. Patterns are emerging, and from these I can guess a little of what’s going on and who’s responsible for it.
Thanks to that oh-so-concentrated media power now owned by a handful of the wealthiest corporations (which a few citizens and legislators dignified themselves resisting the encroachment of) we’re seeing a horrid amount of class antagonism being fostered, presumably for the purpose of causing some deliberate misdirection.
One thing you may hear people saying (or more likely muttering) is something about how “all those illegals and welfare queens are making it big on free healthcare while I sweat paying taxes”.
If anyone bothers to check, the so-called healthcare reform act that was signed into law is functionally identical to the one put out in 2006 by the American Heritage Foundation, that über-right think tank that was a favorite of Rove & Cheney. Like the 2006 original, it was written by and for the healthcare industry in order to foster the continuation of its enormous profiteering. It does not provide free healthcare to all; rather, it demands that everyone must purchase it from a private company – and if you check, guess what, rates are rising sharply.
One supposes that these same corporations that wrote the bill (and plan to profit enormously off their new, enhanced, guaranteed revenue stream) have decided to shift public attention elsewhere by pitting half the population against the other half. All it takes them is a quick request to R Murdoch, who phones up his Faux Nooz Entertainment spin-meisters (and a similar call to the current Jack Welch at GE), and soon enough a couple of the networks are flooded with angry stories & opinion about how unfair it is that illegals, welfare queens, indigent poor, etc, are getting free care. No doubt the few hundred million dollars spent putting a smokescreen over this highway robbery is peanuts compared to the trillions they’ll rake in over the next decade.
Another thing you may heard said is something like “49 percent of the people don’t pay any taxes”.
This one came out right around the time it was learned that Gollum Sacks had its best year ever in the firm’s 149-year history. Of course, “experts” assure us this had nothing to do with their backdoor to Treasury, their illegal high-frequency trading, or any of their other scheister actions. Gollum Sacks paid only a 1% effective tax rate, thanks to its manipulations. Warren Buffet brags openly that he pays a lower tax rate than his secretary. Wall Street seems to have had its best year ever, even while the real economy has tanked horribly. Of course, we’re led to believe this had nothing to do with the billions they get loaned at 0%, which they then sell back to the government at 4%.
But that’s OK, Captain Misdirection is at their service! What better way to distract the people from this bank robbery than to convince them, hook + line + sinker, that their less-fortunate fellow citizens are lazing around enjoying lower taxes than they are? Face it, everyone thinks s/he pays too much in taxes .. and it burns up him/her to think that someone else is getting a lower rate. But poor people are visually familiar to all of us, while rich corporations are faceless far-away entities that most people can’t even name specifically, don’t know the chief officers of, and never deal with directly. When it comes to finding a scapegoat, everyone always goes for the familiar instead of the hidden stuff they don’t know and have never seen.
Another BS line you may hear someone repeating is something like “Oh, all those people on unlimited employment have given up because they’d rather not work at all, and it’s easier to laze around and enjoy the fruits of MY TAXES!” (usually ends in a shriek)
This is another beautiful piece of misdirection. The emotional anger induced by this bit o’ propaganda is enough to overwhelm recognition of the oft-circulated fact that there are six (and now perhaps seven or more) unemployed people for every job out there. Instead of feeling sympathy for our fellow citizens, many of whom have been financially uprooted because their former employers have now outsourced work to cheaper places, we’re induced to feel that they’re a bunch of lazy, freeloading slackers who are just sitting around eating watermelon and pizza all day long in between SUV-trips to the beach and the cinemaplex.
Another line you may hear is “Those people on food stamps are just abusing the program to buy cigarettes and beer”.
Notice how this BS gets ratcheted up every time the new numbers come out saying that one in X citizens is now on food stamps, and that more than a quarter of our nation’s children are now served by the program? Uh-huh. What your outrage is supposed to obscure from you is the fact that the companies most profiting from this arrangement (the same Big Agriculture interests responsible for putting high-fructose corn syrup into so many lower-cost prepared foods) are extremely pleased with this arrangement.
Yes, dear sheeple, instead of noticing how the bank is being robbed by – hey, look, it’s the Goodyear blimp!
Not long ago, after it first became necessary for him to show at least some public antipathy toward BP in light of the horrible oil spill it caused, president Obama said that cozy and long-running relationship between the government and the oil industry has got to end. It is by now reasonably common knowledge that most (if not all) of the people working in the government regulatory agencies that are supposed to monitor and control and limit the oil industry’s excesses are themselves former oil business employees, and that good awl-bidness jobs await them after their “successful performance” (at least to the oil companies) in those regulatory agencies. Many former state and federal representatives are presently in the employ of the oil industry, primarily at firms lobbying the government on behalf of the industry.
What our president unfortunately did not say was that the exact same kind of “cozy and long-running relationship” exists between the government and any industry or party that’s rich enough to lobby it. In each case, the regulatory agencies are staffed by ex-employees of the firms they’re supposed to be regulating. A fine example of what ensues can be found at the SEC, where the staffers found no wrongdoing on Wall Street and instead surfed pr0n from their offices. None of them flagged Madoff’s classic ponzi scheme, or AIG’s disastrously-obscure derivative plays, or Moody’s labeling of dogsh*t-toxic assets as AAA, or Goldman Sach’s high-frequency trading cheats, or more.
Everyone familiar with this blog knows how we got here .. the subject has been amply discussed in the past. I won’t hog bandwidth by repeating it. Suffice it to say, when something you hear or read makes you distrust or dislike or resent any of your fellow citizens (and it’s not something any of them did to you personally), it warrants being /extremely/ curious about who’s going to benefit most from you getting bent out of shape.
June 10, 2010 at 11:47 am
Hi Nudge
Excellent post – how easily people are seduced or convinced that someone doing it much harder than them is living it up large when the truth is that they would probably change places in a heartbeat with the still-employed person who is bagging them.
It’s no different to all the naysayers on PO. The fact that geology doesn’t lie and our ancient stored sunlight is starting to top-out will not get in the way of a chance for a good old-fashioned beat up of people facing and trying to do something to prepare for the future energy declines. These buggers, instead of refusing to acknowledge reality until the very last moment still want to live in the heyday past of the 50s and 60s – well good luck with that!
Our Mr Peak Oil here no longer wastes his energy or money in trying to convince those too stubborn or thick about PO and instead conserves his own energy. He emailed me this week and told me he had had a conversation with the Cuban ambassador to NZ re Cuba’s PO a while back and was told by the ambassador that PO for Cuba meant that it was like a plane losing its wings at 10,000 feet and then plummeting to the ground. Shit I wish I had been there as I’ve total respect for Cubans’ doggedness and willingness to not descend into total chaos despite terrible privation.
Glad to see that BP’s share price has taken a pasting and that shareholders may have their dividends suspended by law.
June 11, 2010 at 3:15 am
Mary, Nudge, great posts. FYI, check out Ilargi’s latest post on TAE, saying much the same that BP may get bailed by US and UK taxpayers, rather than have the “too big to fail” but not too big to frigg up international corporation go BK, see: http://theautomaticearth.blogspot.com/
for the latest depressing oily bird photo.
June 11, 2010 at 6:00 am
Mary & Doom, thank you for commenting. This stuff bugs the bejeebus out of me. The largest and richest corporations are making out like bandits now due to their subversion of democracy, and they’ve found ways to cover it up, divert attention, make sure the sheeple blame each other rather than the entity that’s silently robbing the banks and stealing our future. I guess so many people have been living close to their edge (in regards to income & expenses) and have been pushed right out to the bleeding edge, and maybe right over it, by rising costs & higher taxes.
That part, my friends, is only going to get worse.
As a group, the ones I know personally who are having the hardest time are single older women who bought houses back when the economy is better. Uggh, a house is now going to be a huge liability load (at least here in the UPL) unless you’ve got even moron household income than before.
Mary, you nailed it perfectly with what you said about Cuba: “.. total respect for Cubans’ doggedness and willingness to not descend into total chaos despite terrible privation.”
That will probably be the key difference between the UPL and other places. Here we’re taught from early on that little is more important than feeling good, especially if it involves shopping or ego gratification or driving faster than other people. Quite unconsciously we’re willing to mistreat each other horribly, I think, all in the pursuit of some personal competitive advantage.
Pundits here in the UPL like to point to Cuba as a failed state.
The Cubans, however, point to the UPL and note that their revolution is on its 11th UPL president. They were the ones who had a sane, rational response to the end of cheap oil; we don’t. Their fisheries may well be ruined by our oil mess, which was partly a product of that long-running cozy relationship between the awl bidness and the UPL government’s “no rich corporations left behind” policy.
June 11, 2010 at 10:52 pm
Kudos for an excellent post Nudge, very well said and true, true, true!!!
I have previously mentioned reading Joe Bageant’s book Deer Hunting with Jesus. Much of it details how working class people have been marginalized economically and hoodwinked culturally.
Present day scapgoating is a scary sign that we’re headed towards more of it and that it could get really nasty—like Kristallnacht nasty.
I remember a few years ago seeing an episode of 20/20 with Diane Sawyer reporting on welfare cheats. (This was during Clinton’s assault on welfare.) They did an undercover investigation and what they came up with was so pathetic it was sickening. Things like a woman who got a double payment and didn’t report it—amounted to about $400. Meanwhile her then colleague Sam Donaldson was reported to have qualified for a government grant of $95,000.00 because he was raising sheep on his hobby farm.
Maybe he was raising sheeple for the government.
June 11, 2010 at 11:59 pm
My personal favorite sheeple move from the elites is the institution of the all-volunteer military. It has effectively eliminated all major war protests in the USA since Vietnam. It gives a steady income and career path for the lower classes, so they naturally support a “strong military” (insert waving flags here) unless the fighting gets too hot and some threshold of casualties is crossed. And note that in the ME occupations, a lot of military and political effort is placed in keeping those GI casualties low, but civilians? Too bad.
Unemployment must have the elites worried some. If it gets too high, there could be mass protests or riots.
June 12, 2010 at 1:10 am
Right Doom, the all-volunteer military was the quid to the the middle-class for not sending their kids to war anymore. The quo was that they would no longer complain about military adventures. It’s always self–interest isn’t it?
June 13, 2010 at 6:42 pm
Patz, what I find interesting about the notion of the “all-volunteer army” is that the recruiting is anything but class-blind. Betcha more than half of them in uniform, especially among the enlisted and lower ranks, grew up in households earning less than the median household income.
Unfortunately, ending the draft meant that much of the nation no longer had to care on a personal scale if we’re at war or not, since none of our children or relatives or friends would be affected. Many nations, having already been through just this, insist on maintaining compulsory military service as a means of assuring that war will be personally unpopular among the general population. The Europeans have certainly learned it the hard way
One might well suspect our PTB made this move knowing full well that many informal military misadventures would be in need to maintain western hegemony and in particular do things to maintain the status of the dollar as the world’s reserve currency.
June 13, 2010 at 8:01 pm
In countries or groups with small populations in relation to real or perceived threats (e.g., South Korea), the draft or compulsory military service is there. Thanks to our population boom, in part augmented by right-wing, business-supported immigration laws of late, the military planners have eased off requesting more troops beyond voluntary. There were also some adjustments made to counter the “brain drain” that the all-volunteers represent.
June 14, 2010 at 1:52 pm
Making Afghanistan Pay (beyond the already lucrative CIA-run international opium and guns trade), from today’s TAE:
Afghanistan ‘Holds $1 Trillion In Mineral Deposits’
Afghanistan has nearly $US1 trillion in untapped mineral deposits, far more than previously thought and enough to turn a country devastated by decades of war into one of the most important mining centres in the world, according to senior US officials. The deposits, which include large veins of iron, copper, cobalt, gold and lithium are so large they could alter the Afghan economy, American geologists said after discovering the resources. An internal Pentagon memo says that the country could become the ‘Saudi Arabia of lithium’, a key industrial metal.
“There is stunning potential here,” General David Petraeus, the head of US Central Command, told The New York Times. “There are a lot of ifs, of course, but I think potentially it is hugely significant.” The Afghan government and President Hamid Karzai have been briefed, US officials said. The devastated country has already emerged as the latest frontier in the rush for mineral resources. In April, plans were announced to start mining copper in the Aynak valley, soutwest of Kabul, which holds one of the world’s biggest untapped copper deposits, estimated to be worth up to $88_billion (£44 billion) – more than double Afghanistan’s entire gross domestic product (GDP) in 2007.
In November, a 30-year lease was sold to the China Metallurgical Group for $3 billion, making it the biggest foreign investment and private business venture in Afghanistan’s history. However despite the latest finds, with no mining industry in place it would take decades to develop an infrastructure to exploit the vast mineral reserves which are scattered throughout the country including along the border with Pakistan where some of the most intense fighting has taken place. But US authorities are hopeful that the scale of the deposits is such that they will attract huge investment regardless. “This will become the backbone of the Afghan economy,” Jalil Jumriany, an adviser to the Afghan minister of mines told the newspaper.
June 14, 2010 at 6:29 pm
Doom, this has ominous echoes of Cheney & team’s assertions that the invasion & occupation of Iraq would be totally paid for by the oil we’d secure there by military means. It’s especially scary to hear Petraeus talk about “stunning potential”. No doubt the “bringing democracy to Afghanistan” (cough cough bullsh*t cough) now shares totem pole space with “making sure by military means that the richer nations of the world have got access to Afghanistan’s mineral resources”.
Is this going to be the way of it?
Psst! Yo Petraeous .. heard a rumor that Nigeria has got lots of light sweet crude. Err, and they could really use some of that ‘democracy’ too.
Poor Orwell, he was a prophet. Now we all get to see what he saw. Whole nations going down into the maw of the machine for consumption by others.
June 14, 2010 at 9:33 pm
Don’t even joke about bringing democracy to Nigeria Nudge. Holy crap! then they’d start driving cars, air-conditioning their homes, buying stuff from China and generally behaving like UPLers. Next thing you know an effin’ middle class would want to keep most of the oil for themselves and want a fair price for the rest. You can see where this could go now, can’t you?
June 14, 2010 at 9:45 pm
You’re right, Patz. Let’s just keep them as another corrupt petro-state. Those jungle primitives wouldn’t have any way of getting to the offshore stuff all on their own, let alone refining it afterwards. Heck, considering that we need it and it’s there, it’s practically our oil under their offshore sea floor, right?
June 17, 2010 at 9:48 pm
So true. I can’t really add much to that, except that the wingnuts are trained to screech “CLASS WARFARE!!!!11!!1!” any time someone brings this stuff up. Well, yeah… the class warfare is going on all the time. The poor & middle class aren’t fighting back though.
June 21, 2010 at 6:03 am
http://www.getup.org.au/campaigns/latest.php
Interesting co-opting of a charity auction for humane ends.